Colon cancer screening: Is there an easier, effective way?

Are you, or is somebody you realize, suspending their colonoscopy? Possibly it’s the thought of that prep. At greatest, it requires being house and close to a bathroom for a day. Worse, it may well make individuals really feel awfully in poor health. Or perhaps it’s the invasiveness of the take a look at. At greatest, it’s disagreeable. At worst, there might be severe issues, together with an instrument puncturing the bowel, bleeding, and organ harm. It’s additionally time-consuming, requiring break day give you the results you want and whoever shall be driving you house.

Why is a colonoscopy definitely worth the problem?

Cancers of the colon and rectum are widespread, and lives might be saved with early detection. Colorectal most cancers is the fourth most typical most cancers in the USA and the second main explanation for most cancers demise. There are effectively over one million individuals dwelling with the analysis, and 134,000 new circumstances are anticipated this 12 months. About 4% of all adults shall be recognized with colorectal most cancers of their lifetime; having a first-degree relative with colorectal most cancers or precancerous polyps, a private historical past of polyps, advancing age, weight problems, alcohol use, smoking, and African-American race all improve the chance considerably.(1, 2, 3)

The five-year survival fee for these cancers is about 90% when the most cancers is caught earlier than it spreads in any respect, however solely 68% when it has began to unfold, and 10% when it’s extensively unfold (metastatic).(3, 4) For that reason, specialists agree that it is smart to display individuals at common threat beginning at age 50 and as much as age 75, with the choice to proceed screening after that on a case-by-case foundation.(3, 4)

Based on the 2016 tips from the U.S. Preventive Providers Process Drive (USPSTF), there are six acceptable methods to display for colorectal cancers and precancerous polyps: procedures like sigmoidoscopy and colonoscopy; particular imaging strategies (CT colonography); fundamental stool assessments for blood (as a result of bleeding within the gut generally is a signal of most cancers); the FIT take a look at, which is a fancier, extra delicate stool take a look at for blood; and the mixed stool DNA take a look at that appears for molecules, gene mutations, and blood. Which take a look at to make use of is dependent upon the affected person’s scenario and preferences, and the USPSTF has referred to as for extra analysis so as to have the ability to make extra exact suggestions.(5)

Cologuard: The brand new child on the colon most cancers screening block

Lately my sufferers have been asking about Precise Sciences’ Cologuard mixed stool DNA take a look at, which was authorised by the FDA in 2014. You will have seen it marketed on TV, that includes a cute little speaking field. Medicare and Medicaid will cowl your entire value of this take a look at (about $500) as soon as each three years for average-risk individuals who don’t have any gastrointestinal signs.

The take a look at is easy-peasy. One in every of us goes to the web site and prints out the order kind, the affected person fills within the insurance coverage info, and I signal the paper, which will get mailed to the corporate. They in flip mail the affected person a little bit field with the stool assortment package. The affected person goes about their traditional routine, with none change to weight loss plan or prep in any respect, poops into the cleverly designed rest room cowl/assortment jar, and mails it again to the corporate inside two days. The corporate runs the assessments, and the numerical outcomes from every take a look at element are run by means of a particular equation, with a cutoff rating for a constructive or unfavorable end result.(7) They ship the outcomes to me, after which I report back to the affected person. A constructive take a look at signifies that additional analysis is important, and that includes a colonoscopy on the lookout for a polyp or most cancers.

Simply how good is Cologuard?

Primarily based on the one main examine cited,(6) it’s fairly darned good: Cologuard detected 92% of colorectal cancers and 42% of superior polyps. As a comparability, the FIT take a look at detected 74% of cancers and 24% of superior polyps. So it’s higher than the one different actual non-invasive possibility, and with out the painful prep, potential discomfort, and probably severe dangers of a colonoscopy or CT colonography. (You will need to know that each of those stool assessments usually tend to have a false constructive end result. That signifies that the stool take a look at can counsel most cancers when there isn’t any, and to know for positive, a affected person will want a colonoscopy or CT colonography in any case.) Proper now, the take a look at is roofed by insurance coverage each three years, however extra analysis is required to know if that’s an acceptable interval; ultimately, the take a look at could also be advisable kind of usually than that.

Cologuard sounds so great. And it might really be, however sufferers ought to know that the one main examine that offered the info upon which a lot of the suggestions are based mostly was 100% funded by Precise Sciences, the corporate that makes the take a look at. Even the one different smaller examine displaying related, supporting outcomes was authored by co-inventors of the Cologuard expertise and scientific advisors to Precise Sciences.(8) It’s actually essential to know that, and to take this wonderful little speaking field with an enormous grain of salt. I can perceive why the USPSTF is asking for extra analysis, and why medical doctors aren’t abandoning the nice previous, reliable, however pain-in-the-rear-end colonoscopy as a fundamental screening take a look at. But.

Am I recommending the Cologuard for my very own sufferers? You wager. I’ve many sufferers whom I’ve been encouraging to have their colonoscopies for years, and for one cause or one other, they’ve delayed. Or, there are some sufferers with medical points for whom a colonoscopy could also be logistically troublesome or too dangerous. Of their circumstances, the stool assessments are very viable choices, positively higher than no screening, and perhaps higher than conventional screening. We simply don’t know for positive but.


  1. NIH Nationwide Most cancers Institute: Frequent Varieties of Most cancers.
  2. NIH Nationwide Most cancers Institute SEER (Surveillance, Epidemiology, and Finish Outcomes) knowledge.
  3. Harvard/Massachusetts Basic Hospital Main Care Workplace Perception, chapter on Colorectal Most cancers Screening, by Blair Fosburgh, MD; Wynne Armand, MD; Main Care Operations Enchancment Specialist Reviewers: Daniel Chung, MD.
  4. Screening for Colorectal Most cancers: Methods for Sufferers at Common Threat. Up-to-Date (Wolters Kluwer). Chyke Doubeni, MD, FRCS, MPH. Part Editors: J Thomas Lamont, MD; Joann G Elmore, MD, MPH; H Nancy Sokol, MD.
  5. Screening for Colorectal Most cancers: Up to date Proof Report and Systematic Evaluation for the US Preventive Providers Process Drive. Lin JS, Piper MA, Perdue LA, Rutter CM, Webber EM, O’Connor E, Smith N, Whitlock EP.
  6. Multitarget stool DNA testing for colorectal-cancer screening. Imperiale TF, Ransohoff DF, Itzkowitz SH, Levin TR, Lavin P, Lidgard GP, Ahlquist DA, Berger BM. New England Journal of Drugs.
  7. Complement to: Multitarget stool DNA testing for colorectal most cancers screening.
  8. Stool DNA testing for screening detection of colorectal neoplasia in Alaska Native individuals. Redwood DG, Asay ED, Blake ID, et al. Mayo Clinic Proceedings.

Commenting has been closed for this publish.

Leave a Reply