Harvard Health Ad Watch: A feel-good message about a diabetes drug

Diabetes monitoring tools and chart, stethoscope, and heart-shaped bowl of healthy foods

This 60-second commercial for Trulicity, a drugs for diabetes, is likely one of the most feel-good remedy commercials I’ve ever seen. The narrator by no means makes use of the scare tactic of so many different adverts, itemizing the horrible issues that might occur for those who don’t take the therapy. As a substitute, from begin to end, music, photographs, and spoken phrases ship empowering, encouraging messages centered on serving to your physique to do what it’s speculated to be doing regardless of having diabetes.

There’s loads of good info right here, however as in most direct-to-consumer well being advertising and marketing there’s additionally some that’s lacking. Let’s undergo it, lets?

Three actors, three constructive messages

The advert opens with uplifting music and statements by three folks with sort 2 diabetes (although all are actors, as famous in textual content on the backside of the display). A lady faces the digital camera to declare

“My physique is really highly effective.”

Up to now so good! Then a person carrying a tough hat and holding blueprints at a development website states

“I’ve the ability to decrease my blood sugar and A1C.”

Extra excellent news! By the best way, he’s referring to hemoglobin A1C (HbA1C), a molecule within the circulatory system that serves as a normal take a look at of common blood sugar over the earlier two to a few months. A standard or practically regular HbA1C suggests good diabetic management, whereas larger outcomes point out elevated blood sugar and poorer management of diabetes.

We then meet a 3rd girl carrying scrubs, who works within the bodily remedy division of a hospital. She says

“…as a result of I can nonetheless make my very own insulin and Trulicity prompts my physique to launch it, prefer it’s speculated to.”

Properly, that sounds good, too, proper? Offered this manner, Trulicity appears extra pure, as a result of it encourages the discharge of your physique’s insulin slightly than counting on injected insulin.

What’s Trulicity anyway?

A voiceover tells us Trulicity shouldn’t be insulin, it’s taken as soon as weekly, and it begins performing from the primary dose. Tiny print notes the generic identify (dulaglutide) and the truth that it’s an injection “to enhance blood sugar in adults with sort 2 diabetes when used with food regimen and train.” Then we hear who ought to not take Trulicity, an inventory together with youngsters, folks with Kind 1 diabetes, and ladies who’re pregnant. Potential unwanted side effects are described, similar to nausea, low blood sugar, abdomen issues, and allergic reactions (see full record right here). The FDA requires this in all direct-to-consumer adverts.

Because the digital camera pans as much as solar shining by means of leaves and a band performs within the background, we see the bodily therapist once more — having modified out of scrubs into common garments — at a picnic together with her household. We hear a couple of extra warnings about unwanted side effects and the chance of decreasing blood sugar an excessive amount of when taking Trulicity with different diabetes medicines.

Standing in a fantastic park, the lady faces the digital camera and says

“I’ve it inside me to decrease my A1C.”

Lastly, the voiceover makes the same old suggestion

“Ask your physician about Trulicity.”

What this advert will get proper

The outline of dulaglutide as a non-insulin remedy that stimulates the discharge of insulin is correct. The textual content and spoken details about the remedy, together with who ought to and shouldn’t take it and the attainable unwanted side effects, replicate the FDA-approved prescribing info. And the unstated message — that folks with diabetes will be lively, working, social people — can also be true (and, maybe, underappreciated).

What’s lacking from this advert

Some vital info offered solely in textual content is straightforward to overlook. It seems just for a couple of seconds, and a few of the print is kind of small — they don’t name it fantastic print for nothing! For instance, you would simply miss the truth that Trulicity is out there solely by injection. Equally, you would overlook the textual content explaining that Trulicity shouldn’t be a primary alternative for the therapy of sort 2 diabetes, and that food regimen and train are vital in managing this situation.

Different lacking info consists of

  • the that means and relevance of HbA1C
  • whether or not Trulicity reduces issues of diabetes, similar to kidney illness, nerve injury, or visible issues, or improves high quality of life or longevity; actually, there may be proof it may well scale back cardiovascular issues and dying in high-risk people
  • whether or not Trulicity is best than different therapies for diabetes, together with different injectable therapies that work in an analogous method, oral medicines, or insulin
  • the excessive value of Trulicity: the “record value” is sort of $10,000/12 months, though medical insurance or help applications could decrease the out-of-pocket value.

One different doubtlessly deceptive function of the advert is the selection of actors. Extra weight is a significant threat issue for sort 2 diabetes. But, two of the three actors portraying sufferers, together with the bodily therapist who makes a number of appearances, seem near regular weight. The third seems solely modestly obese.

The underside line

Ads can present loads of helpful info, however they will also be deceptive. Whereas there are rules round what can and can’t be included in adverts for prescription medicines like Trulicity, these rules don’t require commercials to color a full image.

For those who or a cherished one has sort 2 diabetes, there are higher methods to study concerning the choices for therapy than a drug advert. Sure, speak to your physician. However don’t restrict your dialog to one thing you heard or examine in a feel-good drug advert.

Observe me on Twitter @RobShmerling

Commenting has been closed for this publish.

Leave a Reply