Heart failure and salt: The great debate

“Let there be work, bread, water, and salt for all.”
— Nelson Mandela

Salt: with out it, meals can appear tasteless. It’s the cause sea water burns our eyes and pores and skin. Some folks get pleasure from salt water baths. Is it good for us? Is it not? Do we actually know?

In fashionable medication, we are likely to have a usually damaging feeling about sodium, the aspect present in salt. Extreme sodium consumption is linked to water retention, and additionally it is a danger issue for hypertension. Each extreme sodium consumption and hypertension are main danger elements for growing coronary heart failure, and for inflicting problems in these with present coronary heart failure. On condition that 6.5 million American adults have coronary heart failure, limiting salt consumption would possibly profoundly scale back danger for this main medical scourge.

Certainly, we advise our sufferers with coronary heart failure to limit the quantity of salt they devour per day. For years now we have been telling them to steer clear of salty fries and Chinese language takeout, which can have as much as 7,000 mg of sodium in a single meal. We consign sufferers hospitalized for coronary heart failure to a bland “low salt, coronary heart wholesome” food regimen till discharge. However what will we base the low-salt advice on? Is that this simply anecdotal? Or do now we have proof that guides our suggestions?

Within the spirit of open-mindedness, let’s debate this query.

Level: Reasonable sodium consumption is dangerous for folks with coronary heart failure

Sodium consumption is related to fluid retention, therefore the puffiness and bloating that will observe a really salty meal. And extreme sodium consumption might worsen hypertension, or hypertension. Hypertension will increase the chance of growing coronary heart failure and might worsen present coronary heart failure. Hypertension may result in different forms of coronary heart illness, stroke, or kidney failure. A low-sodium food regimen might assist decrease or forestall hypertension, and should scale back the chance of such illnesses.

Excessive-sodium diets are additionally normally excessive in whole fats and energy, which can result in weight problems and its many related problems. Some research additionally recommend that there could also be a hyperlink between sodium consumption and osteoporosis and abdomen most cancers. Moreover, consuming salty meals over an extended time frame can accustom your style buds to the style, and in flip make you extra prone to attain for saltier meals.

Counterpoint: Reasonable sodium consumption will not be dangerous for folks with coronary heart failure

Cardiologists are likely to apply evidence-based medication, but lots of our suggestions relating to sodium consumption for folks with coronary heart failure are based mostly on assumptions. Surprisingly, it’s laborious to say there’s sufficient proof to state past a shadow of a doubt that sufferers with coronary heart failure needs to be restricted to the two,000 mg of salt per day most physicians suggest. And realistically talking, what number of sufferers abide by this restriction stays unclear, as a result of sodium is in nearly all the things we devour.

In a scientific evaluate of 9 research lately revealed in JAMA Inside Medication, solely restricted and inconsistent proof was discovered supporting any advantage of salt-restricted diets for non-hospitalized folks with coronary heart failure. The proof for salt restriction was inconclusive in sufferers admitted to the hospital for coronary heart failure. This was a well-done research; solely 9 of two,655 research evaluated have been rigorous sufficient to incorporate within the evaluate. So maybe most significantly, this evaluate illustrates that whatever the conclusion, rigorous, evidence-based knowledge relating to sodium restriction in coronary heart failure are usually not obtainable.

The lives of our coronary heart failure sufferers are sophisticated sufficient as it’s. It’s crucial that no matter we suggest for our sufferers doesn’t additional worsen the standard of their already tough lives. Since sufferers typically wrestle to take care of adherence to therapies in coronary heart failure, our focus as physicians needs to be on stressing the issues which might be evidence-based. This contains adherence to guideline-directed medical therapies and favorable life-style interventions, reminiscent of extra train, and care of different related medical situations, reminiscent of diabetes.

The decision: Till now we have extra proof, it’s a draw

Take a few of what we are saying with a grain of salt (pun supposed). There’s not but sufficient proof for both aspect of the good salt debate to win. And our dialogue mustn’t lead sufferers to devour salt in extra till we all know for certain. Certainly, within the absence of fine medical knowledge, one should settle for the necessity for good medical judgment: avoiding extreme quantities of sodium is a wholesome transfer for all of us, together with these with coronary heart failure.

It’s additionally extremely possible that some sufferers are extra salt-sensitive than others. Thus, directing salt restriction to these most weak is likely to be higher than a one-size-fits-all method. Research on this space are very a lot wanted. Thankfully, medical trials to handle this query are ongoing, so keep tuned!

Observe Dr. Januzzi on Twitter @JJheart_doc and Dr. Ibrahim @IAmDrIbrahim

Commenting has been closed for this submit.

Leave a Reply