Is there a “best” pain reliever for osteoarthritis?

ARCHIVED CONTENT: As a service to our readers, Harvard Well being Publishing gives entry to our library of archived content material. Please word the date every article was posted or final reviewed. No content material on this web site, no matter date, ought to ever be used as an alternative to direct medical recommendation out of your physician or different certified clinician. 

Osteoarthritis (OA) impacts tens of hundreds of thousands of People and is a number one explanation for incapacity and decreased high quality of life throughout the globe. Aside from joint alternative surgical procedure, there isn’t any identified “treatment” for OA, and most therapies give attention to aid of signs akin to ache. Usually, step one is non-medication-based approaches akin to bodily remedy, train, and weight reduction. Most sufferers, nonetheless, will ultimately use ache relievers akin to non-steroidal anti-inflammatory medication (NSAIDs). Other forms of medicine, akin to opioids, have additionally been examined as therapies for OA, and there’s ongoing debate about what therapies are greatest.

NSAIDs vs. opioids: Was there a transparent winner?

A latest examine in contrast oral NSAIDs and oral opioids for aid of osteoarthritis ache. Researchers at Harvard-affiliated Brigham and Ladies’s Hospital carried out a meta-analysis (that’s, they mixed and summarized the outcomes of quite a few printed research). They included medical trials wherein sufferers with knee osteoarthritis (KOA) have been chosen at random to obtain therapy that lasted not less than 2 months.

The researchers rigorously selected which research to incorporate, and two members of the staff independently reviewed every examine and extracted the info. They chose research that used a typical, well-validated, and widely-accepted measure of ache (the WOMAC scale, which charges ache on a scale from 0 to 100). Information from over 5,500 sufferers have been included, and the researchers discovered that, on common, oral NSAID therapy decreased ache by round 18 factors on the WOMAC scale. Remedy with much less potent oral opioids (akin to tramadol) additionally decreased ache by round 18 factors, and potent oral opioids (akin to oxycodone) decreased ache by round 19 factors on the WOMAC scale. Since, on common, sufferers began out with ache scores of round 50-60 out of 100, every of those medicines achieved round a 30% discount in sufferers’ ache.

Briefly, every of those medicines helped scale back ache, and their results have been about an identical. The discovering of a roughly 30% discount in ache could be very in line with research of many therapies for persistent ache. Whereas we’re pretty good at acute ache administration, many persistent ache situations akin to OA, low again ache, and others are tougher to deal with successfully. Many researchers within the subject consider {that a} multidisciplinary staff (which incorporates well being care suppliers with completely different backgrounds) working collectively to make use of a variety of completely different approaches to handle ache gives the simplest means of managing persistent ache. And there’s good proof for the effectiveness of those sorts of therapies. For instance, a affected person with extreme KOA would possibly: be handled with NSAIDs prescribed by her main care doctor; see a bodily therapist to work on strengthening and conditioning the leg muscle groups; obtain occasional steroid photographs within the knee to alleviate irritation and ache within the joint; and see a nutritionist to assist with food regimen and weight reduction, which relieves stress on the joint and may considerably scale back knee ache.

Working towards a personalised strategy to ache administration

This meta-analysis can not inform us which of some of these medicine (if any) ought to be prescribed for a specific affected person. No examine can. The person-to-person variation within the effectiveness of any KOA therapy is large. One affected person might get near-total ache aid whereas one other shouldn’t be helped in any respect. These findings do give clinicians a benchmark for the “typical” quantity of ache aid that may be anticipated from these medicines, and counsel that, since they work about equally nicely, the selection of which one to make use of might be influenced by issues aside from effectiveness. Suppliers and people struggling with persistent ache additionally have to weigh potential unintended effects. Remedy (particularly long-term therapy) with oral NSAIDs can lead to abdomen issues like bleeding, ulcer, and abdomen upset, in addition to hypertension and kidney issues. Opioids can have unintended effects akin to constipation, nausea, and drowsiness. As you’re additionally probably conscious, opioids are additionally related to a danger of significant overdose and dependancy.

Many people within the subject of ache administration are hopeful that ultimately we can extra successfully “personalize” ache therapy on the premise of a person’s traits, and his or her probably responses to a specific therapy. It’s price noting that non-medication therapies akin to train, weight reduction, and enhancements in food regimen typically have few or no unintended effects, and have advantages that reach past aid of knee ache (for instance, enhancements in coronary heart well being). For most individuals, these therapies ought to be included as part of their multidisciplinary ache administration program, whatever the medicine choices being thought-about.

Commenting has been closed for this publish.

Leave a Reply