Screening mammograms: One recommendation may not fit all

Thus far, official suggestions on when and the way typically a lady ought to have a screening mammogram, have been based mostly on danger elements (akin to age, a household historical past of breast most cancers, a private historical past of radiation to the chest), genetic testing (the BRCA check, for instance), or troubling outcomes from a earlier biopsy. Race and ethnicity haven’t formally factored into the equation — but.

Does race matter on the subject of screening mammograms?

A latest research by Harvard medical doctors at Massachusetts Basic Hospital reinforces prior knowledge suggesting that race and ethnicity is usually a separate danger issue for breast most cancers, and needs to be taken into consideration when advising ladies on when and the way typically to have a screening mammogram.

The authors studied virtually 40 years of knowledge in a large, publicly obtainable US analysis data financial institution known as the Surveillance, Epidemiology, and Finish Outcomes (SEER) Program, and recognized over 740,000 ladies ages 40 to 75 with breast most cancers. They wished to know if the age and stage at analysis differed by race.

It did. White ladies’s breast cancers are likely to happen of their 60s, with a peak round 65. Nonetheless, black, Hispanic, and Asian ladies’s breast cancers tended to happen of their 40s, with a peak round 48. As well as, a considerably increased proportion of black and Hispanic ladies have superior most cancers on the time of analysis, when in comparison with white and Asian ladies.

This matches with prior research, together with a separate evaluation of knowledge from SEER in addition to the Middle for Illness Management’s Nationwide Program of Most cancers Registries (NPCR). They discovered that non-Hispanic white ladies are likely to have the least aggressive breast most cancers sort, whereas black ladies are likely to have essentially the most aggressive sort, in addition to extra superior illness at analysis.

Mainly, there are dependable knowledge to recommend that we take race and ethnicity into consideration once we counsel sufferers about when to begin mammograms and the way typically to have them. Whereas many medical doctors are conscious of the information and are sharing this data with sufferers, it’s not a part of “official” tips.

So what are the official tips for screening mammograms?


Breast most cancers screening has turn into an space of some controversy, with at the least six totally different US organizations providing various opinions, roughly in the identical ballpark (give or take 10 years, that’s). For the common lady with out the chance elements listed above, the suggestions vary from

Each lady over age 40 ought to have a mammogram yearly, however, it’s a shared decision-making course of so discuss it first (American School of Obstetrics and Gynecology)


Begin at age 45 after which yearly till age 55, then each different yr (American Most cancers Society)


Begin screening mammograms at age 50 and have them each different yr (United States Preventive Companies Job Power).

This variability appears complicated, however what’s constant is that every one tips suggest a shared decision-making course of. Meaning a lady ought to discuss together with her physician to find out when to first have a screening mammogram, and the way typically she ought to have one.

Causes a lady would possibly not wish to begin screening mammograms at age 40

Aside from some awkwardness and discomfort, why wouldn’t a lady wish to begin screening mammograms at age 40? Each screening check carries some danger, together with pointless extra imaging and biopsies. The concept is that by beginning screening later, the chance of catching most cancers early isn’t outweighed by the dangers of screening. A lot of my sufferers have gotten that dreaded callback after their mammogram: “We see one thing which may be trigger for concern and wish you to return for added photos.” That is nerve-racking and entails extra radiation publicity. If the realm continues to be worrisome, then a biopsy could also be finished. Most biopsies are adverse, and even when optimistic, we don’t know for certain that every one low-grade, localized cancers are going to progress. We deal with them once we discover them for certain, but it surely’s potential that not everybody will profit from lumpectomy and radiation or mastectomy.

What do ladies have to find out about screening mammograms?

Docs ought to counsel ladies precisely about their dangers and advantages for most cancers screening, and whereas tips are useful, they’re solely tips. We have to know the place the rules got here from, what knowledge was used to create them, and — most significantly — what knowledge have been not used to create them. Within the case of breast most cancers screening, race and ethnicity haven’t but been formally included within the present tips, and girls want to pay attention to that and what it means for them.

Commenting has been closed for this publish.

Leave a Reply