Tai chi may be as good as physical therapy for arthritis-related knee pain

ARCHIVED CONTENT: As a service to our readers, Harvard Well being Publishing offers entry to our library of archived content material. Please observe the date every article was posted or final reviewed. No content material on this website, no matter date, ought to ever be used as an alternative choice to direct medical recommendation out of your physician or different certified clinician. 

Osteoarthritis — the age-related, “wear-and-tear” type of joint illness — is the commonest sort of arthritis. And the knee is essentially the most generally affected joint. The truth is, virtually half of the inhabitants can have knee ache as a result of osteoarthritis by age 85. There is no such thing as a remedy; the one everlasting remedy is a complete knee substitute. Greater than 700,000 of those operations are carried out within the U.S. annually, and the speed of knee substitute surgical procedure has practically doubled between 2000 and 2010.

Since surgical procedure is a final resort, what are you able to do within the meantime? The mainstays of remedy embrace losing a few pounds if you’ll want to, train, varied ache relievers and anti inflammatory drugs, and bodily remedy. However these approaches don’t at all times work properly. In the event that they did, we’d have far fewer joint substitute surgical procedures!

Contemplating how frequent osteoarthritis of the knee is and the way restricted our therapies are, information of a novel method to treating osteoarthritis of the knee comes none too quickly.

A brand new examine evaluating tai chi and bodily remedy

Boston researchers publishing within the Annals of Inner Drugs describe a examine of greater than 200 adults with painful knee osteoarthritis. Half the members have been randomly assigned to plain bodily remedy and the opposite half have been assigned to tai chi, a “conventional Chinese language mind-body observe that mixes meditation with gradual, light, sleek actions; deep diaphragmatic respiration; and leisure” (as described within the examine). Every course of remedy lasted 12 weeks.

Why did the researchers undertake this analysis? Preliminary research had demonstrated that tai chi has clear advantages for individuals with osteoarthritis, however no earlier examine had in contrast it instantly with customary bodily remedy. And prior trials had discovered that tai chi can assist deal with situations like rheumatoid arthritis and fibromyalgia (amongst others).

This new examine discovered that

  • each the bodily remedy and tai chi teams noticed important enhancements within the quantity of ache they skilled, and every group’s ache improved to an analogous diploma.
  • the enhancements the members noticed by 12 weeks lasted for a full 12 months.
  • the tai chi group improved greater than the bodily remedy group in measures of despair and in sure measures of high quality of life.

One limitation of many research of tai chi is that a few of its impact could also be associated to the persona or charisma of the trainer. On this new examine, the investigators considered that and in contrast completely different instructors; no variations between them have been famous.

Which might you select?

Does this imply you need to select tai chi as an alternative of bodily remedy in case you have knee osteoarthritis? That’s not how I’d interpret the outcomes — in spite of everything, the primary discovering of the examine was that each therapies have been equally efficient at relieving ache. But it surely does lend credibility to the concept tai chi might be useful. It’s additionally recognized to have many extra advantages in addition to ache aid, and it’s typically thought-about fairly secure. So if it’s one thing you’d be prepared to attempt, go for it!

What about price?

One distinction between bodily remedy and tai chi for osteoarthritis is that tai chi shouldn’t be often coated by medical health insurance. I discovered courses within the Boston space for round $20 per session, which implies the full price of 24 periods of tai chi (the variety of periods the examine members obtained) could be about $480.

What’s subsequent?

This examine was comparatively small and lasted just one 12 months — but osteoarthritis signs can final a long time. So, we’ll want bigger and longer research of tai chi in osteoarthritis earlier than we will confidently say that it’s a long-term remedy for a long-term situation. Nonetheless, this new report is encouraging. Not so way back, proponents of “complementary and various” therapies reminiscent of tai chi routinely met resistance from sufferers and docs who wished to see proof that these therapies truly work. Lately, that long-awaited proof has begun piling up. This new examine is simply the most recent instance.

Commenting has been closed for this submit.

Leave a Reply